Abstract: To carry out the forecast of meteorological data in order to perform an analysis of the solar and wind potential of
the Camilo Daza airport of the city of Cúcuta, multilayer Perceptron-type neural networks configured with 9 4-4layer neurons and 10 times or
iterations are used to adjust the procedural variables of the regression. For this, the methodology presented by Jorge Aguilera and Leocadio
Hontoria and the Weibull probability density distribution are used, with the intention of guaranteeing a lower initial investment with
adequate and complete use of the solar system, the wind system and the bank of batteries, so that the cost / investment / benefit ratio is
viable.
Keywords: Hybrid System, Neural Networks, Solar Radiation, Wind Speed, Weibull.
Resumen: Para realizar el pronóstico de datos meteorológicos con el fin de realizar un análisis del potencial solar y eólico
del aeropuerto Camilo Daza de la ciudad de Cúcuta, redes neuronales multicapa tipo Perceptron configuradas con 9 neuronas de 4-4 capas y 10
tiempos o las iteraciones se utilizan para ajustar las variables de procedimiento de la regresión. Para ello se utiliza la metodología
presentada por Jorge Aguilera y Leocadio Hontoria y la distribución de densidad de probabilidad de Weibull, con la intención de garantizar una
menor inversión inicial con un uso adecuado y completo del sistema solar, el sistema eólico y el banco de baterías, de modo que que la
relación costo/inversión/beneficio sea viable.
Palabras clave: Sistema Híbrido, Redes Neuronales, Radiación Solar, Velocidad del Viento, Weibull.
1. INTRODUCTION
Fossil fuels account for more than 79 per cent of the world’s primary energy consumption. The production of electricity generates, among other
effects, the emission of nitrogen oxides (NOx) and carbon dioxide (〖CO〗_2), greenhouse gases and the main responsible for climate change
.
It is now established that electricity generation is responsible for producing 35% of the world’s carbon emissions, hence the importance of
renewable energy, since its implementation involves the use of clean and inexhaustible short-term natural resources for energy generation, In
addition to this, the use of hybrid systems optimizes electricity production through a more versatile installation in terms of system power
reliability requirements and climatic conditions.
Renewable energies are energies that are automatically renewed by themselves in nature, and are obtained from natural sources which, due to
their duration, quantity and self-generation, can be called inexhaustible.
,
,
There are a large number of ways to make use of renewable energies, however, the most relevant and most welcome forms of installed capacity
are:
Solar energy originates from fusion reactions that occur in the core of the sun, which emit energy in the form of short-wave radiation that
travels through space and reaches the atmosphere. The average solar radiation received by the earth is between 1300 and 1400 (W⁄(m^2)). These
values vary according to climatic conditions, which in turn depend on the geographical location (latitude and longitude) and the period of the
year.
,
,
,
On the other hand, wind energy is obtained through the surrounding wind currents over a specific location and bases its operation on the use
of kinetic energy generated by the effect of air currents, to be converted into electricity in order to improve the energy consumption of a
community.
;
;
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Hybrid System.
Hybrid systems refer to the concept of joining two or more types of renewable energy, this in order to merge operatic characteristics of each
system and obtain efficiencies higher than those that could be achieved with the application of a single energy source.
;
In this sense, there are several factors that affect the dimensioning of a hybrid renewable energy system, such as, among others, the loads
borne by the installation and the meteorological variables in situ. Therefore, the criterion by which these installations are dimensioned is
carried out with more attention to the reliability of the system. Reliability means to ensure the proper functioning of the system while
assuring that the failures are minimal.
2.2 Neural Networks.
One of the challenges facing our generation is the development of agents that emulate the complex behavior of a human brain to solve problems
that cannot be solved by a traditional algorithmic approach.
,
,
. Artificial neural networks (Rnas), far from being models parallel to a human brain, achieve the development of certain characteristics that
make it function similarly. Well, they have phases of learning, abstraction and generalization of a problem as the data is presented.
. There is a great diversity of neural network models, however, this research chooses to implement the Perceptron Multilayer, due to its
efficiency in regression and prognostic problems.
;
,
The Multilayer Perceptron is a type of neural network that consists of an input layer, a certain number of intermediate layers or hidden
layers, dedicated to data processing and an output layer. Usually, all neurons in one layer are connected to all the neurons of the next layer
in a forward propagation scheme (feedforward) so that the input data is directed towards the output layer while being transformed by the
hidden layers.
;
2.3 Programming Environment.
The code of the neural network and the processing of the data are worked in the programming language python, because it is a freely
distributed and developed software, nevertheless, it possesses high level characteristics that makes its codes flexible and with a clear
syntax. In addition, being a multi-paradigm programming language, it supports types of programming such as object orientation, imperative
programming and to a lesser extent functional programming.
,
,
.
In order to contribute projects that promote the use of renewable resources in a practical, simple and reliable way, the present research aims
to analyze the solar and wind potential of the Camilo Daza airport in the city of Cúcuta, to size a hybrid renewable energy system through
weather data forecasting. To do this, we use Perceptron multilayer neural networks configured with 9 neurons 4 layers and 10 epochs or
iterations that adjust the procedural variables of the regression.
3. RESULTS
From the equations and models described above, certain results are obtained. These are used to determine the viability of the selected
methodology, as well as the energy and computational efficiency of the system, when dimensioned with meteorological data, product of a
forecast.
3.1 Meteorological characteristics.
The analysis of renewable energy resources available in the area, through multi-year averages of data frequency and statistical methods and
Machine Learning to estimate the solar-wind potential, so that the start of the research, is feasible.
The selection of the Camilo Daza airport as an object of study, lies in the Camilo Daza Airport Station of the Institute of Hydrology,
Meteorology and Environmental Studies IDEAM, which, provides the Wind Speed and Solar Radiation data necessary to design the hybrid system, it
should be noted, that this data, were measured at a height of 10 meters above the surface.
They have a level of "Definitive" approval (granted by IDEAM), which indicates that this data has gone through the necessary technical
validation process, thus guaranteeing the quality of the data for analysis and implementation.
Table 1: General Airport Data Camilo daza
Characteristic |
Value |
Altitude |
405 MSNM |
Coordinates |
7ponl 55 39 N -72[ 30 42 O |
Operator |
Orient and Aerocivil airports |
For global solar radiation, a total of 1371 daily data of the average incident radiation at 10 meters above the surface are available, which
are distributed in two sets. A first set will contain the data for training the neural network and the second set will contain the data for
testing or validation. It should be noted that, of the total data, 70% is used for training and 30% for prognosis. On the other hand, for the
wind speed two data intervals are available in order to provide a historical record to the neural network to optimize it´s prognosis.
Fig. 1. Radiation Meteorological Characteristics and Wind Speed Airport Camilo Daza
The data set used to train the network has a total of 1832 measurements of wind speed at 10 meters above the surface and meets the parameter
of a normal distribution, with the speeds between 1-2 and 2-3 being the most repeated.
For the neural network design and testing data set, it consists of 1309 daily average wind speed measurements at 10 m above the surface, with
a standard deviation of 2.383621 and an overall average of 4.218525 m/s. b) The frequency of measurements meets the criterion of normal
function, therefore the range 2-3 m/s (c) is the most likely and most frequent data. Also, the probability of finding wind speeds greater than
4 m/s is 39.648 %. Additionally, it can be seen that the pattern of wind speeds is similar to that of the training set, which indicates the
continuous nature of the records.
Training of the neural network.
Since the Multilayer Perceptron will be used as a type of pre-powered neural network, the hyperbolic tangent activation function is chosen, in
addition, the mean quadratic equation (MSE) and the mean absolute error (MAE) are used as optimization parameters. of error.
With regard to the selection of the number of layers, neurons and iterations or epochs, it is decided to emphasize computational performance
in order to select said parameters.
Proposed Model |
Number of Layers |
Number of Neurons |
Configuration #1 |
3 |
Range [1, 20] |
Configuration #2 |
4 |
Range [1, 20] |
Configuration #1 featured a hidden layer, an input layer, and an output layer. Although less than 10% of adjustment errors were obtained, with
the increase of neurons in the occult layer, the algorithm lost stability and a cyclic behavior with unexpected peaks incurred throughout the
prediction process.
Fig. 2. Configuration Response #1
On the other hand, Configuration #2 (An input layer, two occult layers and an output layer), shows a greater stability in the forecast, with a
downward trend in its metric and values close to 5% of error in the adjustment of the synaptic weights, In addition, relatively low changes in
error can be observed when the Perceptron Multilayer has more than nine neurons in its structure. In conclusion, the Artificial Neural Network
of the Multilayer Perceptron type will consist of four (4) layers and nine (9) neurons in their occult layers.
Fig. 3. Configuration Behavior #2
Subsequently, with neurons and layers defined, the number of epochs with which the response of the Multilayer Perceptron was optimized or,
failing that, maintained was selected. This process was carried out with the layers and neurons selected in the previous section. In
conclusion, a neural network composed of four layers (4), nine neurons in their occult layers (9) and ten epochs (10) shall be used.
Fig. 4. Convergence of the model with each iteration
The training of the multilayer perceptron released two trained models (Radiation Model and Wind Speed Model). Each of the trained models has
different adjustments and tolerances to the prediction of data, however, the differentiating factor is represented mainly by the amount of
data with which the training was conducted.
First of all, the training of the Perceptron multi-layer neural network for the wind speed data set, evidences a downward error trend with
each iteration, this is due to the number of historical records used to train the neural network and the optimal selection of network
convergence parameters. In addition, it can be seen that, during the training phase, the error in the regression of the data was close to 12%,
while in the validation phase the error remained close to 16%. This behavior indicates a favorable response of the neural network to data that
has not been manipulated. (See Fig. 5 andFig. 6)
Fig. 5. Error Trend in Wind Speed
Finally, the data forecast for the solar radiation set was made. It should be noted that this set does not have a historical record of
measurements, since the equipment that takes these values is in operation since 2015, therefore, the neural network faces the problem of
finding a radiation pattern with a reduced amount of data.
Fig. 6. Wind speed forecast
As can be seen in Fig. 7, the behavior of the error in the set of radiation data is variable, however, tends to stabilize at 18.5% in the
training phase. In addition, in the validation phase, the error behavior is descending with each iteration and tends towards 19.7 %.
Fig. 7. Global Radiation Set Error
Although the error rate in the training and testing phase is very high, the behavior of the neural network is acceptable, since, as mentioned
above, it does not have enough data to establish a value pattern, Therefore, the accuracy of the forecast varies considerably. It is also
evident that the function generated by the prognosis of the multilayer Perceptron, presents a graphic typology similar to the real data,
however, the model did not satisfactorily estimate the synaptic weights and, therefore, presents disaggregated data. (See Fig. 8)
Fig. 8. Global Radiation Forecast
From the data obtained, the selection of the optimal angle of inclination of the photovoltaic panel is made, through the application of the
critical month method. This method gives us an optimal angle of 10 ³ and an overall solar radiation on a sloped surface of 3213.62 Wh⁄m^2 .
On the other hand, the calculation of the components of the photovoltaic system was carried out, from the input parameters of the algorithm
and the previously selected values of radiation and inclination.
Table 3: Operational characteristics of the solar panels.
Property |
Nominal Value |
Inclination angle |
10 [ |
Solar radiation on inclined surface |
3,213 kWh⁄m2 |
Photovoltaic Module Peak Power |
250 Wp |
Photovoltaic Module Voltage |
24 V |
Photovoltaic Module Performance |
75 % |
Amount of Panels |
10 panels |
Panel Structure |
(10X1) 10 parallel panels, 1 in series |
In second place, the operational characteristics for the battery, inverter, and regulator are established based on the system input
parameters.
Table 4: Battery, regulator and inverter characteristics
Property |
Nominal Value |
Battery Nominal Capacity in (Wh) |
53086.42 Wh |
Battery Nominal Capacity in (Ah) |
2211.94 Ah |
Battery Voltage |
24 V |
Battery Autonomy Days |
4 days |
Discharge Depth |
50% |
Regulator Maximum Current |
66.92 A |
Inverter Nominal Power |
4837.5 W |
Inverter efficiency |
90% |
Once the calculations to dimension the photovoltaic arrangement are done, the next step is to design a wind system with the wind speed data
analyzed in the chapter.
To start, the Weibull probability function shape and scale parameters are estimated, which show very similar values. However, the method of
moments shows better adjustment to the wind speed data. Furthermore, according to
;
, the maximum probability method leads to errors in some cases.
Afterwards, the monthly power density was calculated at 10 meters above surface, where the maximum generated power observed is 108.01 Wh⁄m^2
in the month of June.
It is important to highlight that such data were adjusted to a power coefficient of 0.45, which is due to the fact that the three-bladed wind
generator was selected as subject of study, and it has a power coefficient that varies between 0.4 and 0.45
Finally, the probability to find wind speed above 3 m/s (starting speed for wind generator) is found, which is given in the Weibull
probability function by the equation, and it has as a result of 65.34%, that is, 5645.3 hours a year, wind speed above the starting speed can
be found. Therefore, the wind generator theoretical nominal power is 609.75 kW.
Fig. 9. Power generated withthe wind speed regime analyzed
Afterwards, the operational characteristics of the wind generator are established on Table 5
Table 5: Operational Characteristics of the turbine
Property |
Nominal Value |
Nominal Power |
609.75 kW |
Starting speed |
3 m⁄s |
Folding speed |
25 m⁄s |
Amount of vanes |
3 units |
Height |
10 meters |
In conclusion, the hybrid system is going to be formed by ten panels with a nominal power of 250 Wp (each), an energy storage system with a
capacity of 2211.94 Ah, four day-autonomy and a discharge depth of 50%, an inverter with a nominal power of 4837.5 W, a regulator with a
maximum current of 66.92 A and a three-bladed wind turbine with a nominal power of 609.75 kW.
It is important to remark that for the preliminary dimensioning of the system, certain efficiency values and other equipment characteristics
were assumed, therefore, the reference values for the components have an operational slant.
4. CONCLUSIONS
This type of study generates a great social impact in favor of human well-being and sustainable technological development since energy supply
is directly proportional to the development level and life quality of people.
The research environment of this proposal consists of seeking, in a practical and efficient way, to estimate the necessary equipment to
perform a hybrid renewable energy installation, through the analysis and weather data forecast supplied by IDEAM. In that context, some
assessments were drawn.
The solar resource analysis through the normal distribution showed that the data range that presents a higher repetitiveness is 5-6 kWh⁄m^2
with a multiannual average for years 2015-2019 of 5.223 kWh⁄m^2 and 4.7 peak solar hours, besides, the probability to find radiations above
the threshold of 4 kWh⁄m^2 is 82.78%. Because of this, the metropolitan area of the city of Cúcuta, represents a great attractive for
photovoltaic applications at a large scale and at domestic level.
Regarding the wind potential at Camilo Daza airport in the city of Cúcuta, the likelihood to find wind speed above 4 m⁄s is 39.648 % and the
data that presents the highest repetitiveness is in the range of 2-3 m⁄s, therefore, the information in the wind speed map that establishes an
average wind speed for the metropolitan area of Cúcuta between 3-4 m/s is validated, because the starting speed of the wind generator is m⁄s,
the turbine generates energy 65.34 % of the year. It is necessary to remark that, in spite of the functioning time of the turbine being 5645.3
hours a year, the wind speeds recorded in the zone at 10 meters high, are not appropriate for the development of wind application at a large
scale; nevertheless, projects at domestic level or which require a lower energy consumption, can be supplied by this resource.
Python is an appropriate language for the development of software that fosters scientific research, since it is a programming language that
allows carrying out analysis, forecast and representation of weather samples contained in databases in a more simple and interactive way, due
to the dynamic typing in the code lines and a great number of specialized libraries that can be used. Therefore,
Python’s Keras library offers great opportunity to develop artificial intelligence models in a few code lines and with good results, as long
as the parameters that have influence on the adjustment of the synaptic weights of the neuronal network are properly selected, an example of
this is the multilayer Perceptron that was developed throughout this research, since in the training stage, diagnosis errors lower than 13%
were obtained for wind speed and an error of 19.7% in the data set for solar radiation were obtained. While it is true that the obtained slant
is relatively large compared to the amount of supplied data, the Perceptron type multilayer neuronal network adjusted the parameters to carry
out the forecast appropriately.
The Perceptron type multilayer neuronal network chosen to carry out the forecast (4 layers, 9 neurons y 10 stages) adjusted acceptably to the
time series comprehended by the wind resource and the solar resource and settles the research basis for the development of a compact
dimensioning method that, by means of the application of artificial intelligence, allows the design of installations of renewable energy.
REFERENCES
Andrade, E. (2013). Estudio de los principales tipos de redes neuronales y las herramientas para su aplicación. 152.
Basogain, X. O. (2015). Redes Neuronales Artificiales Y Sus Aplicaciones. Medicina Intensiva, 29(1), 13–20.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0210-5691(05)74198-X
Figueroa, A., & Mejía, E. (2014). Sistemas híbridos: alternativa de energización en
zonas no interconectadas. 1, 21.
GALLEGO, N. S. (2016). DISEÑO DE UN SISTEMA HÍBRIDO EÓLICO SOLAR PARA EL BOMBEO DE AGUA.
Universidad Tecnológica de pereira.
González-Páramo, L. M. (2017). HERRAMIENTAS AVANZADAS DE ANÁLISIS DE DATOS DE APLICACIÓN EN
INGENIERÍA CIVIL.
GONZALEZ, E. A., & YARA, W. V. (2009). IMPLEMENTACIÓN DE UN SISTEMA HÍBRIDO EÓLICO-SOLAR PARA SUPLIR LA DEMANDA
ENERGÉTICA DE UNA CABAÑA EN LA GRANJA EXPERIMENTAL VILLA MARINA (1 (ed.); 1st ed.).
Gutiérrez, C. (2015). Role of Non-Conventional
Energy Sources in the Colombian electricity sector.
HENRY OSWALDO BENAVIDES BALLESTEROS, OVIDIO SIMBAQUEVA FONSECA, H. J. Z. L.
(2017). Atlas de Radiación solar ultravioleta y ozono de colombia.
Martínez, J. Á. (2017). Aprendizaje supervisado en conjuntos de
datos no balanceados con Redes Neuronales Artificiales Métodos de mejora de rendimiento para modelos de clasificación binaria en diagnóstico
médico. 137.
Pasini, J., & Director. (2019). Diseño de un sistema alternativo eólico para generación de corriente eléctrica.
Universidad nacional de mar de plata.
Perceptron, E. (2016). Perceptron multicapa 3.1. Introducción. 15–32.
Rashid, A.
(2019). APLICACIONES DE DEEP-LEARNING A LA PREDICCIÓN DE RADIACIÓN SOLAR. Universidad complutense de madrid.
Rico, J. C. S.
(2007). ANÁLISIS DE LAS CARACTERÍSTICAS DEL VIENTO Y POTENCIAL DE ENERGÍA EÓLICA PARA CÚCUTA - COLOMBIA Serrano. 8o Congreso Iberoamericano De
Ingenieria Mecanica, 18(18), 8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.riai.2012.02.005
Serrano Rico, J. (2013). Comparación de métodos para
determinar los parámetros de Weibull para la generación de energía eólica. Scientia et Technica, 18(2), 315–320.
https://doi.org/10.22517/23447214.7823
Tutor:, D. C. O. (2018). Inteligencia Artificial con TensorFlow para predicción de
comportamientos.
UPME. (2015). Plan Energetico Nacional Colombia: Ideario Energético 2050. Unidad de Planeación Minero Energética,
Republica de Colombia, 184.
UPME, & BID. (2015). Integración de las energías renovables no convencionales en Colombia. In
Ministerio de Minas y Energía. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781107415324.004
Voyant, C., Notton, G., Darras, C., Fouilloy, A., &
Motte, F. (2017). Uncertainties in global radiation time series forecasting using machine learning: The multilayer perceptron case. Energy,
125, 248–257. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2017.02.098