ISSN Electrónico: 2500-9338
Volumen 23-N°1
Año 2023
Págs. 18 – 36
TEACHER TRAINING IN POSITIVE PSYCHOLOGY AS PART OF THE
INTERNATIONALIZATION OF THE CURRICULUM. INTERNATIONALIZATION OF THE CURRICULUM.
AN ETHNOGRAPHIC STUDY
Miguel Armando Vélez Tellez*
Enlace ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0006-9133-9684
Marcos Pérez Mendoza**
Enlace ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5194-8366
María
Cruz Cuevas Álvarez***
Enlace ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2349-5344
Fecha
de Recepción: 15 de Diciembre de 2022
Fecha
de Aprobación: 1 de Abril 2023
Resumen:
The
objective of this paper is to describe the training process oriented towards
positive psychology as part of the internationalization of the curriculum
directed to teachers of a Mexican public institution of higher education. The
method is ethnographic because in educational research it allows a description
or reconstruction of a scenario or cultural group. The techniques used were
documentary review, literature review and participant observation with a
moderate gradient of observation. Among the findings, the virtues developed by
the participants are highlighted: humanity, temperance, transcendence and
justice. Certain considerations are suggested to avoid resistance to change as
well as a follow-up to evaluate the duration of the training effect.
Key
words: Internationalization of the curriculum, teacher
training, positive psychology.
*Universidad
Juárez Autónoma de Tabasco, Universidad Juárez Autónoma de Tabasco, Maestría en
Auditoría, Institución: Universidad Juárez Autónoma de Tabasco- Adscripción. División
Académica de Ciencias Económico Administrativas- Mexico. Contacto:
miguel.velez@ujat.mx
**Universidad Juárez Autónoma de Tabasco, Doctorado en
Ciencias Económico Administrativas. Mexico. Contacto: marcos.perez@ujat.mx
***Universidad Juárez Autónoma de Tabasco, Doctorado en
Administración Educativa. Mexico. Contacto: maria.cuevas@ujat.mx
INTERNACIONALIZACIÓN DEL
CURRÍCULO. UN ESTUDIO ETNOGRÁFICO.
Resumen
El
objetivo de este trabajo es describir el proceso de formación orientado hacia
la psicología positiva como parte de la internacionalización del currículo
dirigido a docentes de una institución pública mexicana de educación superior.
El método es etnográfico porque en la investigación educativa permite describir
o reconstruir un escenario o grupo cultural. Las técnicas utilizadas fueron la
revisión documental, la revisión bibliográfica y la observación participante
con un gradiente moderado de observación. Entre los hallazgos se destacan las
virtudes desarrolladas por los participantes: humanidad, templanza,
trascendencia y justicia. Se sugieren ciertas consideraciones para evitar la
resistencia al cambio, así como un seguimiento para evaluar la duración del
efecto de la formación.
Palabras
clave: Internacionalización del currículo, formación del profesorado,
psicología positiva.
FORMAÇÃO DE
PROFESSORES EM PSICOLOGIA POSITIVA COMO PARTE DA INTERNACIONALIZAÇÃO DO
CURRÍCULO.
INTERNACIONALIZAÇÃO
DO CURRÍCULO. UM ESTUDO ETNOGRÁFICO.
Resumo
O
objectivo deste artigo é descrever o processo de formação orientado para a
psicologia positiva como parte da internacionalização do currículo dirigido aos
professores de uma instituição pública mexicana de ensino superior. O método é
etnográfico porque na investigação educacional permite a descrição ou
reconstrução de um cenário ou grupo cultural. As técnicas utilizadas foram a
análise documental, a revisão da literatura e a observação participante com um
gradiente moderado de observação. Entre os resultados, destacam-se as virtudes
desenvolvidas pelos participantes: humanidade, temperança, transcendência e
justiça. Sugerem-se algumas considerações para evitar a resistência à mudança,
bem como um acompanhamento para avaliar a duração do efeito da formação.
Palavras-chave:
Internacionalização do currículo, formação de professores, psicologia positiva.
1. INTRODUCTION:
In
Mexican higher education institutions there is a lack of teacher training in
socioemotional competencies that has been accentuated since the COVID-19
confinement. Professors in their teaching role show certain attitudes that
sometimes are not aligned with the institutional values of their work center
and that also have repercussions on their academic relationships with their
academic peers and students.
In the
university chosen to carry out the study, there are problems generated due to
the lack of temperance, sense of justice and sense of humanity, which in turn
generates conflicts and problems of an academic nature. The student becomes
just another student with a myriad of obligations and ready to receive certain
treatment from the teacher, which he/she must abide by and comply with, even if
it is not in the appropriate manner.
Since
entering the institution, students have been taught, during the induction
course, what their role as a student is, what the educational model of the
institution is and what the school regulations consist of, leaving aside the
development of institutional values that should be reflected in the actions of
both the student and the teacher, conduct that should prevail in the teacher as
he/she is the daily role model for his/her students.
In 2022,
based on the observation of various problems arising in the institution, a
diagnosis was made on the type of training needed to remedy the problems
detected. The institution, with the
support of a civil association, generated an Instructional Manual supported by
a Diploma in Educational Psychology for its teachers with the purpose of
developing values called virtues, as well as their dimensions or strengths
under the model of authors Peterson and Slingman with the PERMA methodology.
The
objective of this study is to describe the training process oriented towards
positive psychology as part of the internationalization of the curriculum for
teachers in a Mexican public institution of higher education.
Globalization
is a phenomenon that led "to economic, technological and scientific trends
that directly affect higher education and are inevitable in the contemporary
world" (Altbach, et al., 2009: 23).
Derived
from these trends, education was forced to make a change and include a new
paradigm called internationalization of higher education defined by Knight
(2008: 21) as "the process of integrating the international, intercultural
or global dimension into the purpose, functions or outcomes of higher
education''.
In
25 years, the international dimension has become a priority for national
agencies, international organizations, NGOs and civil associations involved in
higher education public policies. The internationalization of higher education
is an issue that involves various social actors in the following contexts:
political, economic, social, cultural and academic (De Wit and Jones, 2014).
Concepts
and definitions of internationalization
The
concept has undergone transformations from the contributions that each
researcher has made in the last 30 years, starting from International
Education, to International Dimension to the concept of Internationalization
that is known today. The following authors and definitions were adapted from
Aguilar-Castillo and Riveros- Angarita (2017):
Harari
(1989) was able to define it as international education means not only being
part of the curriculum, international student/academic exchange, cooperation
programs with society, but also involvement, attitude, global understanding and
orientation to dimensions that transcend institutions and form international
ethics.
Arum
and Van de Water (1992) considered it as a set of various activities, projects
and services related to international research, educational exchange,
international and technical cooperation. Knight (1994) stipulated that it
allowed the integration of international and intercultural international and
intercultural dimensions into the teaching, research and service functions of
the institution.
Van
der Wende (1996) distinguished the definition on two levels:
(a)
Global: All efforts to respond to requirements and challenges posed by
globalization.
b)
Institutional: Curriculum development and curricular innovation aimed at
integrating the International Dimension even in the teaching method.
For
Ellingboe (1996) it was a multidimensional and interdisciplinary orientation
that includes a dynamic management to respond and adapt accordingly in the
context of changing globalization. Rudzki (1998) added that it was its
presentation as a promoter of excellence in university functions. Continuous
and integral process of its integration in all aspects of the university
educational system as understood by Schöormann (1999).
De
Wit (2001) considered it a strategic process that aims to integrate
international and cross-cultural dimensions or perspectives in the material
functions. And from the perspective of Gacel-Ávila (2009) conceptualized as an
educational process that integrates global, international, intercultural,
comparative and interdisciplinary dimensions is an essential function of the
university in the educational process, providing students with a global
perspective that sustains the values and attitudes of a responsible, humanistic
and supportive global citizenship.
The
internationalization of higher education continues to be in force after almost
three decades that were forced by the phenomenon of globalization, turning the
generation of knowledge into the new world economy supported by technology and
the learning of a second language. This change in turn led to the adaptation of
educational policies that meet three qualities: relevance, quality of education
and education with expected results (Quinteiro Goris, 2020).
The
quality of education also aims to ensure the effective performance of future
professionals by defining quality cycles of efficiency, effectiveness, equity
and relevance. The aim is to meet the needs of today's society by providing
relevant, pertinent and complete knowledge in all fields of knowledge. In other
words, to create favorable training spaces where teaching skills and knowledge
can be improved as part of the personal, professional and institutional
commitments of teachers (Cuevas Álvarez, et al, 2022).
Various
authors over time set themselves the task of categorizing the process, as well
as their internationalization strategies, Cuevas Álvarez and Pérez Mendoza
(2020, p. 251) explained them in their document and present a conceptual model
of internationalization of Mexican higher education:
-Internationalization
at Home: international/intercultural dimension in the formal/non-formal
curriculum for students immersed in domestic learning (Beelen and Jones, 2015).
-Internationalization
of the Curriculum: student-centered, experience-focused learning that seeks
to:
1)
Connect with different cultures, perform in different disciplines with active
participation of teachers in the internationalization of the curriculum;
2)
Teachers with intercultural experience should also be involved (Leask, 2014).
-Internationalization
by Competencies: development of new skills, knowledge, attitudes, and values in
students, faculty, and administration.
The more emphasis there is on education outcomes, the greater the
interest in identifying and defining global/international competence (Knight,
2005) including Intercultural Competence that serves as an instrument of
mediation and reconciliation, promotes integration and social cohesion.
Currently, organizations need to train their staff in this competence.
For
Deardoff (2004) it is the ability to communicate effectively and appropriately
in intercultural situations based on intercultural knowledge, skills and
attitudes. It allows knowing and avoiding intercultural differences or clashes
in interaction processes. This intercultural competence is an essential
characteristic of an inclusive society and as a mediation/reconciliation tool,
it also promotes integration and social cohesion (European Council, 2008). It
involves encoding and decoding processes, including gestures, looks, postures,
silences, clothing, use of space, among others (Rizo, 2009).
Deardoff's
model of Intercultural Competence (2004) is a cyclical sequential model that considers
four stages and three dimensions to evaluate this competence:
a)
attitudes with its indicators: respect, openness, curiosity and discovery,
b)
knowledge and understanding, where the person demonstrates cultural
self-awareness, deep cultural knowledge and sociolinguistic awareness, as well
as the ability to listen, observe, analyze, interpret, evaluate and interact
c)
in the desired external outcome, the person is expected to observe that he/she
can maintain effective and appropriate communication and behavior in an
intercultural situation.
This
Intercultural Competence can be studied qualitatively, making use of the
following data collection tools: a) case studies, b) interviews, c) narrative
diaries, d) self-report instruments, e) observation by others, f) judgment of
self and others, g) with indicators or h) triangulation. It is worth mentioning
that the techniques of narrative diaries and self-reporting should be reviewed
and analyzed by an expert in Intercultural Competence.
-Comprehensive
internationalization: commitment through action, thus creating an institutional
ethos and values in university life. Supported by the leadership and
institutional governance of the entire university community, a desirable
requirement (Hudzik, 2011).
Internationalization
of the Curriculum
This
concept arose from the process of globalization and internationalization of
higher education and was included in the educational programs of higher
education institutions (Gacel-Ávila, 2009). This began with the adaptation in
the wording of the units or learning outcomes of university educational
programs for students to develop competencies during their professional
training (Kennedy, 2007).
Tobón
(2008) defined competencies as the skills that allow activities to be carried
out and problems to be solved in order to contribute to personal development
and the construction of the social fabric. This type of skills combined with
the experience and interaction with people from other cultures has allowed
students to experience and awaken a global awareness (Hernández, 2009).
These
competencies, named by De Zan, et al. (2011) as international competencies, are
necessary to face problems specific to the disciplinary field in a creative and
innovative manner, but which in turn, according to Fantini (2009), allow
students to behave or conduct themselves as responsible citizens with a
commitment to society.
The
internationalization of the curriculum indicates the conditions to create their
own learning scenarios for those who have not had the opportunity to live an
intercultural experience and develop a global competence (McGill & Matross,
2013). Leask (2014) defined this concept as the way to engage students in
internationally informed, linguistically and culturally diverse citizens to
perform effectively as global professionals.
The
internationalization of the curriculum is a phenomenon that arises from the
internationalization of higher education with the aim of training graduates
prepared to face the new social and market reality derived from the
globalization process (Betancour and Farfán, 2015).
In
Mexico, higher education institutions [HEIs] have made efforts to develop
cultural awareness through the internationalization of the curriculum by
implementing academic and student exchange programs (Cuevas Álvarez, 2018).
Deficiencies
in reading and comprehension skills have also been detected (Velázquez Martínez
and Pimienta Rosales (2018). As well as
the need to train teachers in international competencies, also called global, and
in intercultural ones (Salazar Ibarra and Cervantes Holguín, 2018).
Strategies
for the internationalization of the curriculum
Among
the strategies that can be implemented are five that are explained below (UV,
2022):
1. Comparative evaluation or benchmarking:
It consists of being attentive to the changes that arise in the different
areas: both of knowledge and of the environment in general at local, national
and international levels in order to compare and evaluate themselves in order
to adapt the contents aligned to this new global reality.
2. International and intercultural
competencies in the graduate profile: Allows teachers to instruct their
students to identify different, creative or innovative solutions through
international documentary review, exchange information with professionals of
the same discipline and appreciate the cultural differences among them.
3. Virtual collaboration: Development
of global competencies and learning alternatives with the inclusion of
technology that in turn allows the establishment of intercultural relationships
in other contexts.
4. Curricular flexibility: Including
transferable credit system, dual degree programs and mobility.
5. Language learning: Using the
available resources of the institution, such as: language center, self-access
center, conferences, seminars, courses and international internships.
From
this last strategy, intercultural competencies are derived, which a graduate of
tertiary education requires to be considered a citizen of the world, as well as
a series of transversal competencies, (Deardoff, 2011) that allow having
knowledge about other cultures to be able to interact in such a context, with a
receptive attitude that stimulates the establishment of lasting relationships
(UNESCO, 2013).
These
competencies have become required to the point that the Organisation for
Economic Co-operation and Development [OECD] to mention one example, has
included the assessment of global competencies in the guidelines of the
international PISA test (OECD, 2018). However, Germany like other countries
decided not to assess the competency in the next cycle due to the fact that
they require preparing their students to be able to meet the set quality
standards (Sälzer and Roczen, 2018).
Positive
Psychology
Mental
health is not reduced to a happy life, but to a bittersweet process; a life
that does not avoid pain, but faces it and gives it a constructive meaning,
making the painful and contradictory aspects of life good and worth living
(Cuadra and Florenzano, 2003).
Positive
psychology arises from the ravages of the Second World War, being the creator
of the concept Seligman in 1998. He argues that character traits can be
improved through empirical or conceptual tools functioning as an organizing
principle of the individual and social being.
Virtues are core characteristics or universal values that whoever
possesses them, demonstrates them above a certain value.
Strengths
are the psychological aspects that define virtues. The model proposed by the
authors mentions six virtues with 24 strengths (Peterson and Seligman, 2004).
Figure 1.
Note:
Adapted from Peterson and Seligman (2004).
This
approach seeks to achieve a balance by understanding the positive aspects of
human beings and helping to repair or alleviate their discomforts (Martínez
Martí, 2006). Character strengths are often described as universal or
generalized in all people, regardless of ethnicity, culture or religion
(Niemiec, et al., 2012).
However,
a particular strength expressed in a cultural setting can often provide a
unique expression of strength. Many times character strength is different for
different purposes depending on culture, cultural norms and rituals. It is
relevant to keep in mind possible ethnocentric biases in wanting to apply
Peterson and Seligman's classification only from an imposed perspective
(Christopher and Hickinbottom, 2008; Rashid, et al., 2013, Snyder et al.,
2011).
To
understand how to achieve wellness pathways or PERMA (Seligman, 2012), which is
an acronym that encompasses the five main factors around which the theory
revolves. Developing and refining each of these will go a long way in improving
personal satisfaction and motivation.
Figure 2.
PERMA Model
Source:
Castro (2020).
1)
Positive emotions: This means increasing the number of positive emotions, not
as compensation or exchange of negative emotions, but as a means to cope with
negative emotions.
Positive
emotions allow us to experience happiness in our lives, such as peace,
gratitude, satisfaction, joy, inspiration, hope, curiosity or love.
2)
Commitment: It is a pact or personal agreement to achieve harmony between the
two to be in a state of harmony, affinity, fluidity of consciousness. That is,
a commitment to find actions that lead to optimal flow or activation. When we
commit to a task or project, we experience a state of flow in which time seems
to stop and we lose our sense of identity and focus on the present.
3)
Relationships: Given the circumstances of undeniable social existence, it is
clear that this factor can be confirmed as essential to well-being. It is a
protective and supportive factor which makes it relvant. Therefore, enhancing
this aspect can improve personal wellbeing, which also implies improving
interpersonal skills.
4)
Purpose: It refers to the search of belonging to something bigger than oneself.
Its idea is that the meaning of our life transcends ourselves. Thus, the
realization of each objective gives it a transcendent meaning based on the
relevant meaning. We all need to give meaning to our lives in order to be
happy.
5)
Achievement: This means setting goals that, if achieved, will make people feel
empowered and promote autonomy, in other words, achieving the goal in addition
to personal improvements.
Literature review
Among
the studies identified, seven descriptive quantitative studies were found with
samples ranging from 159 to 590 users, in which the aim was to verify whether
virtues, as well as strengths, depend on the following aspects: age, gender or
educational level. In addition, other studies used Seligman's inventory based
on his 6-dimensional model with 24 items.
Of
the other three papers found, one of them is a mixed study with 378 people of
Argentine nationality and adult age, where neither age nor gender was an aspect
that impacted the study, however, the results suggest that the VIA instrument
be adjusted according to cultural variables. In the last two cases, the two
papers mention that they were qualitative studies, of which one is a theoretical
review on the topic and the second is about a positive psychology program or
training.
The
theoretical review concludes that for an efficient emotional education program
to exist, the following phases must be followed: analysis of the context,
identification of needs, formulation of objectives, planning, execution and
evaluation. It emphasizes that teachers should be trained in emotional
competencies.
In
the case of the Happy Classrooms program, it confirms the development of
certain virtues or values in students: solidarity, respect and cooperation; and
recommends that in order to form global citizens, teachers must understand how
the world in which they live works in order to prepare their students with the
vision of a fair and supportive world.
Table
1. State of the art
Author
Year Approach Results/Findings
Autor Año Enfoque Resultados/Hallazgos Castro Solano 2017 Estudio mixto Fortaleza frecuentes: integridad, persistencia, bondad y amor. No se
encontraron diferencias según sexo y edad. Y la clasificación VIA debe
ajustarse en función de variables culturales. Muñoz Campos,
et al. 2018 Cuantitativo
descriptivo Los resultados mostraron una correlación significativa entre la
satisfacción vital y el bienestar subjetivo en profesores. Bisquerra y
García 2018 Cualitativo,
revisión teórica Para la eficiencia de los programas de educación emocional se
recomienda seguir 6 fases. La puesta en práctica de una educación
emocional eficiente requiere de una formación del profesorado: es imprescindible
que el profesorado desarrolle sus competencias emocionales. Santamaría-Cárdaba 2018 Cualitativo,
observación participante El programa Aulas Felices funcionó adecuadamente despertando los
siguientes valores: solidaridad, respeto y cooperación. García, et
al. 2019 Cuantitativo
descriptivo Adecuada satisfacción con la capacitación desarrollando 5 virtudes:
excepto justicia. Laudadío y
Mazzitelli 2019 Cuantitativo
descriptivo El grado de habilidades emocionales es medio-bajo. En la formación
docente será necesario que puedan identificar sus habilidades emocionales
como punto de partida de su desarrollo profesional. Barrientos,
et al. 2019 Cuantitativo
descriptivo El profesorado tiene la percepción de no haber sido instruido en
habilidades socioemocionales y siente la necesidad de ser formado en
ellas para poder gestionar sus clases de manera positiva. Cabrera-Gómez,
et al. 2020 Cuantitativo
descriptivo transversal Las fortalezas detectadas en la población ecuatoriana fueron:
perseverancia, amabilidad, espiritualidad y ánimo. Llorente, et
al. 2020 Cuantitativo
descriptivo transversal Las profesoras tuvieron más elevado el nivel de competencias
socioemocionales que los profesores. García Cruz,
et al. 2022 Cualitativo, Revisión
teórica Los docentes no han sido estudiados y que han sido afectados por la
crisis sanitaria. Se propone incrementar factores positivos usando técnicas
cognitivo-conductuales y de P.P. en una intervención para el
funcionamiento psicológico positivo en docentes.
Castro
Solano 2017 Mixed study Frequent strengths: integrity, persistence, kindness and
love. No differences were found according to sex and age. And the VIA
classification should be adjusted for cultural variables.
Muñoz
Campos, et al. 2018 Quantitative descriptive The results showed a significant
correlation between life satisfaction and subjective well-being in teachers.
Bisquerra
and García 2018 Qualitative, theoretical review For the efficiency of emotional
education programs it is recommended to follow 6 phases. The implementation of
efficient emotional education requires teacher training: it is essential that
teachers develop their emotional competencies.
Santamaría-Cárdaba
2018 Qualitative, participant observation The Aulas Felices program worked
adequately awakening the following values: solidarity, respect and cooperation.
García,
et al. 2019 Quantitative descriptive Adequate satisfaction with the training
developing 5 virtues: except justice.
Laudadío
and Mazzitelli 2019 Quantitative descriptive The degree of emotional skills is
medium-low. In teacher training it will be necessary for them to be able to
identify their emotional skills as a starting point for their professional
development.
Barrientos,
et al. 2019 Quantitative descriptive The teaching staff has the perception of
not having been instructed in socioemotional skills and feels the need to be
trained in them in order to manage their classes in a positive way.
Cabrera-Gómez,
et al. 2020 Quantitative descriptive cross-sectional The strengths detected in
the Ecuadorian population were: perseverance, kindness, spirituality and
encouragement.
Llorente,
et al. 2020 Cross-sectional descriptive quantitative Female teachers had higher
levels of socioemotional competencies than male teachers.
García Cruz, et al. 2022
Qualitative, Theoretical
review Teachers have not been studied and who have been affected by the health
crisis. It is proposed to increase positive factors using cognitive-behavioral
and P.P. techniques in an intervention for positive psychological functioning
in teachers.
4.
The
ethnographic method in educational research allows for a description or
reconstruction of a scenario or a cultural group (Goetz and Hansen, 1974;
Wolcott, 1975, Spradley and McCurdy, 1972), which in turn provides a space for
appreciation of the situation through a detailed description to be credible
(Erickson, 1973).
The
qualitative techniques used were documentary review (Restrepo and Tabares,
2000), literature review (Purdue, 2022) and participant observation with
moderate gradient of observation (Spradley, 1980). The first technique was used
to analyze information that would provide the theoretical basis for the
concepts of internationalization of the curriculum, teacher training and
positive psychology.
positive
psychology. The second technique was used to review recent works or the state
of the art on the subject, as other authors call it. With the last one, it was
possible to know the topics addressed during the training, as well as the
attitudes and behaviors of the teachers.
The
objective of this study is to describe the training process oriented towards
positive psychology as part of the internationalization of the curriculum aimed
at teachers of a Mexican public institution of higher education.
Context
The
Universidad Juárez Autónoma de Tabasco [UJAT] is located in southeastern
Mexico. It is made up of 12 academic divisions located throughout the state of
Tabasco, with its headquarters in the capital city of Villahermosa. It has
approximately 2,500 professors, a number that is in constant change due to
leaves by COVID-19 or for reasons of early or mandatory retirement.
In
the second semester of the school year, during the August-December period,
there is a high number of applications for admission, and after admission, an
Induction Course is held. In 2022, the content of this course was modified to
include the Positive Psychology approach, for which 159 teachers from the
different divisions of the institution were trained by the Civil Association
Ayudándoles a Triunfar (Helping Them Succeed).
Access
to the field
The
field encompasses "the physical and social context in which the phenomena
under investigation take place" (Rodríguez et al., 1999, p.103). In this
case, the observers were at the same time participants in the training, they
had to carry out and deliver the activities as well as form a team with the
other participants, so access to the field and to the participants occurred
naturally.
Procedure
The
researchers collected the information in a notebook or class diary because with
this technique it is possible to write down what happens in each session
(Zabalza, 2004). During the participant observation, the following ethical
principles were kept in mind: ensuring the anonymity of all participants and
the confidentiality or agreement of the purposes of administration and
dissemination of identifying information. The information collected in the
notebook or class diary was analyzed through categories detected by the
researcher, based on the documentary review and literature review.
Excerpts
of information shared by the participants in the written communication media of
the Microsoft Teams platform, images of audiovisual and visual materials, as
well as motivational messages to their fellow trainees are shared.
Learning
and verbal comments made during the observed sessions are also shared and are
presented as part of the analysis of the virtues detected: humanity,
temperance, transcendence and justice.
In
order to maintain the anonymity of the participants, only the messages and
materials were shared without any method of identification. The participants
were coded with the key PA, PB PC and so on.
Findings
The
diploma course in Educational Psychology was conducted during the
inter-semester period from June 20 to July 8, 2022 in virtual format (60 hrs.),
from July 25 to August 8 in classroom format (42 hrs.) with additional hours
for reading and individual work (18 hrs.), making a total of 120 hrs. prior to
the start of the induction course in classroom format.
Contents
of the Diploma in Educational Psychology
The
format and topics addressed in the course for UJAT teachers are related to the
development of virtues with their corresponding character strengths, which are
detailed below:
Descripción de los contenidos
temáticos del Diplomado en Psicología Positiva
Virtud |
Fortaleza
1 |
Fortaleza
2 |
Fortaleza
3 |
Fortaleza
4 |
Fortaleza
5 |
Sabiduría
y conocimiento |
Creatividad |
Curiosidad |
Juicio |
Amor
al aprendizaje |
Perspectiva |
Coraje |
Valentía |
Perseverancia |
Honestidad |
Entusiasmo |
|
Humanidad |
Amor |
Bondad |
Inteligencia
Social |
|
|
Templanza |
Humildad |
Prudencia |
Autorregulación |
Perdón |
|
Trascendencia
|
Apreciación
de la belleza y la excelencia |
Gratitud |
Esperanza |
Humor |
Espiritualidad |
Justicia |
Trabajo
en equipo |
Equidad |
Liderazgo |
|
|
Nota:
Adaptado de UJAT (2022).
The
concepts of each of the virtues were defined in the class sessions and related
to their corresponding strengths based on what is indicated in the Instructors
Manual document, from which the following definitions were adapted:
(a)
Wisdom: complete and deep knowledge acquired through study or experience
enables a person to act correctly and wisely. It is also associated with
emotions ranging from the simplest to the most complex, from curiosity about
the world to a visionary vision of the world.
b)
Courage: This emotional force means exercising the will to achieve objectives
in difficult situations, whether external or internal. The person who acts with
courage stands out for acting with determination and enthusiasm, especially in
the face of danger or difficulty.
c)
Humanity: It means caring for others by offering friendship and affection to
others. It is the capacity to feel affection, understanding or solidarity with
others. It involves demonstrating interpersonal strengths based on concern and
intimacy through love, kindness and social intelligence, which lead to positive
attitudes towards society in general.
d)
Temperance: It is a human quality that makes one perform activities with
moderation.
e)
Transcendence: It is the connection with the vast universe and gives meaning to
life. It implies daring to go out of ourselves and realizing that we are an
integral part of a universe.
f)
Justice: It is the civic power that ensures a healthy social life. It is the
tendency to give to each one what is due to him. People with this virtue do
what is just, equitable or lawful.
Attitudes
of the participants at the beginning of the course
At
the beginning, as in any process of change, there was some disagreement or
resistance on the part of the teachers, not because of their age or gender, but
because of their personal attitude. The change of paradigm of learning to
unlearn and relearn, terms used during the training, is a gradual process that
implies accompaniment and guidance so that participants do not give up
throughout the program.
The
change of the use of the word concept or dimension for virtue, as well as the
term value for strength, caused discomfort and disagreement among the academic
and scientific community, who were of the opinion that they were probably going
to start singing, praying and even meditating and floating. This attitude is a
typical reaction of defense or resistance to not accept the new learning and it
is common to make jokes about it or to dismiss what they want to teach.
In
the case of spirituality, which is a strength of the virtue of transcendence,
there was tension when hearing from the participants that they were in a
Juarista institution, that is, a secular institution; that education in Mexico
is secular and that topics such as religion should not be mixed because it is
controversial and is not allowed by statute, much less for moral and ethical
issues.
There
was also active participation by those participants who knew about the topic,
who valued the information shared and created balance between the comments and
restored control of the session both in writing in the chat and verbally during
the first two sessions.
Subsequently,
there was a change from jokes and dismissal to fear of participating or mockery
of what was shared because it was time to open up to others and express
feelings, emotions, challenges achieved or dangers overcome. Fear of crying in
the middle of the storytelling, fear of being singled out or fear that the
information would be used for other purposes contrary to the objective of the
training.
Other
participants did not wish to use their voice, but wanted to express their
feelings through other formats: a poem, mentioning a song, through the story of
a series, movie or simply in the obligatory activities or deliverables in which
only the instructors had access.
Attitudes
of the participants at the end of the diploma course
During
the week of face-to-face activities, teachers were observed with the following
attitudes that are not typical of the program, but are typical of the attitudes
of intercultural competencies and that arose as a result of its implementation:
openness, empathy, respect and tolerance. In the team activities, in the
support with didactic materials, in the spaces for emotional expression and the
great majority wanted to share their experiences without fear or embarrassment.
The
change of attitude in the teachers was perceptible, contrary to the initial
attitudes. Active participation, attentive listening, collaborative work,
willingness to change, assertiveness, companionship and solidarity were
observed.
PA:
Good morning, could someone from the Justice team tell me what the assignment
is please? There is the assignment but no instructions. Thank you for your
attention.
PB:
Good evening, excuse me, do you know which are the activities of module VIII,
the assignment is only available to attach the document but it does not say
what they consist of and I cannot access where the recording of the session was
made.
PC:
Check in archives. Inside your new group!
PA:
Thank you very much, I will check it.
PB:
Ok I am on 1 now I will check. Thank you very much.
Some
more tech-savvy people were advising others to avoid damage to their computers:
PS:
Hi, good afternoon, those files that start with dot and underscore, they are viruses,
try not to download them or it will damage your compu, it is a bit cumbersome
but don't download them all together, it worked for me downloading one by one
and avoiding the probable viruses, greetings and happy afternoon!
Participants
felt the confidence to share materials related to the diploma and their topics
without the fear of others making fun or negative comments about it.
Figure 2.
Video
shared by a participant
Figure 3.
Image
shared by a participant
Figure 3.
Image shared
by a participant
Based
on Peterson and Slingman's model (2004), the virtues developed by the
participants and detected at the end of the course are as follows
Humanity
Strengths:
Love, kindness and social intelligence.
Participants
shared their knowledge and life experiences by communicating in an empathetic
and assertive manner.
Temperance
Strengths:
Humility, prudence, self-regulation and forgiveness.
In
this case it was not a matter of gender but a matter of academic nature and
status as a researcher. It was a bit complicated to accept that one does not
know
everything
and that having a certain academic degree or status as a research professor
does not exempt a person from making mistakes or not always being right.
Sometimes the ego or embarrassment was present, the discomfort or shame of
being labeled as someone who does not know was noticeable.
Transcendence
Strength:
Gratitude
It
is a word that the vast majority omitted even in the most everyday cases such
as when they clear a doubt or answer a question, it is taken for granted that
the other understands that they are being thanked, but the participants
realized that in most occasions it should be verbalized not only to be
perceived but also to register in the memory.
Justice
Strengths:
Teamwork, fairness and leadership.
Although
being a group of university professors, it would be inferred that they know how
to work with the previously mentioned strengths, nevertheless, as mentioned in
the virtue of temperance, ego or grief is present. It was difficult at the
beginning to cede control or power to another person, even if it was for
short-term activities. Consenting on decisions and delegating activities was
done with fear at the beginning, a situation that gradually changed until they
felt like equals when working together.
5.
It
is considered that the participants in this study developed attitudes of
intercultural competence derived from the training received in the diploma
course in Educational Psychology by continuously practicing the virtues of
humanity, temperance, transcendence and justice.
In
the case of the attitudes of openness and empathy, because in humanity we work
on empathy and assertive communication. In temperance, prudence and self-regulation
are worked on, which are related to the tolerance that must be shown to others.
In justice, respect is put to the test when delegating activities and
recognizing leadership in others, but also because in order to be equitable,
the workload limits of each member of a work team must be respected.
The
participants were simultaneously developing international, global,
intercultural and socioemotional competencies based on the educational
psychology model, without this being the intention of the course. The materials
and activities used and implemented also influenced these findings. The
audiovisual and visual materials were not exclusively from Latin America, they
were materials from other cultural contexts and that conjugates with what was
mentioned by Rashid (2013), the cultural context influences the type of
strengths that are developed.
6. CONCLUSIONS:
The
findings obtained allow understanding under what type of scheme a training for
the development of socioemotional skills or competencies of educational
psychology should be delivered, specifically with Peterson and Seligman's
model.
It
is suggested that to avoid resistance to change as observed in this study, from
the beginning, instructors should use the concept of values instead of virtues,
as well as that of dimensions over that of strengths and gradually modify the
terms, this being a key recommendation expressed by some participants during
the observations.
Another
key suggestion is that certain language should be sought when covering
spirituality as a strength. In this case, this institution is Juarista whose
premise is that education is secular, in all of Mexico public education is
secular, so avoid using vocabulary that refers to dogmas and limit yourself to
concepts such as superior energy, superior being, or any other expression that
refers to a deity without mentioning a particular name.
The
participants demonstrated to have appropriated the virtues or socioemotional
competencies by conducting themselves in the classroom with the expected
performance, in the same way they conducted themselves in the corridors, in
their interactions with classmates in spite of the number of hours of daily
training and confined in the same space respecting the established social distance.
We conclude by proposing a continuity to the observations to verify the
duration of the effect of the training, who continue to demonstrate their
skills, who would need reinforcement or new activities so that the effect does
not fade with time.
Aguilar-Castillo,
Y. y Riveros- Angarita, A. (2017). La internacionalización de la educación
superior: Concepto y evolución del modelo en la Universidad de Costa Rica. Revista
Educación, 41(1), 1-31.
Altbach,
P. G.; Reisberg, L. y Rumbley, L. E. (2009). Trends in
Global Higher Education. Tracking
an Academic Revolution.
UNESCO.
Barrientos
Fernández, A., Sánchez Cabrero, R., y Arigita García, A. (2019). Formación
emocional del profesorado y gestión del clima de su aula. Praxis &
Saber, 10(24), 119-141.
Beelen,
J. y Jones, E. (2015). Europa llama: Una nueva definición para la
internacionalización en casa. International Higher Education, 83(1),
13-15
Bisquerra,
R. y García, E. (2018). La educación emocional requiere formación del
profesorado. Revista del Consejo Escolar del Estado, 5(8), 15-27.
Cabrera-Gómez,
C. C., Rengifo-Rengifo, L., Suárez Hernández, J. M., Rivera-Porras, D. y
Carrillo -Sierra, S. M. (2020). Fortalezas de carácter según género en personas
de salinas de Guardas: perspectiva de intervención desde el Modelo PERMA a la
economía solidaria. Archivos venezolanos de farmacología y terapéutica, 39(2),
226-241.
Castro
Solano, A. (2017). Virtudes y fortalezas del carácter en población adulta de
Buenos Aires. Un esrudio con un enfoque mixto émico/ético. Summa Psicológica
UST, 14(1), 23-32.
Castro,
S. (2022, 26 de septiembre). Modelo PERMA. Instituto Europeo de Psicología
Educativa. https://www.iepp.es/modelo-perma/
Cuadra,
H. y Florenzano, R. (2003). El Bienestar Subjetivo: Hacia una Psicología
Positiva. Revista de Psicología de la Universidad de Chile, 12(1),
83-96.
Christopher,
J. y Hickinbottom, S. (2008). Positive psychology, ethnocentrism, and the disguised
ideology of individualism. Theory
& Psychology, 18(5),
563-589.
Consejo
Europeo [CE]. (2008). Livre blanc sur le dialogue interculturel. Consejo
Europeo.
Cuevas Álvarez, M. C.
(2018). La interculturalidad como reto académico para la internacionalización
en universidades del sureste de México. Educación Global, 22(1), 38-49.
Cuevas Álvarez, M. C. y
Pérez Mendoza, M. (2020). Internacionalización de las Instituciones de
Educación Superior Mexicanas: un modelo conceptual. En G. Martínez Prats, F.
Silva Hernández, R. R. Rentería Ramos y O. L. Ostos Ortiz (Ed.), Estudios
sociales y administrativos en América Latina (pp. 247-259). Colombia: Universidad Abierta y
a Distancia.
Cuevas-Álvarez, M. C. .,
Pérez-Mendoza, M. . y Arias-Moguel, G. U. (2022). Actividades de
internacionalización del currículum implementadas con alto compromiso
docente. Revista de Investigaciones Universidad Del Quindío, 34(2),
94–106. https://doi.org/10.33975/riuq.vol34n2.922
Cuevas-Álvarez,
M. C. ., Pérez-Mendoza, M. . y Arias-Moguel, G. U. (2022). Un acercamiento a la
internacionalización del currículo en una IES tabasqueña. Un estudio de caso.
En Martínez Prats, G. y Silva Hernández, F. (Eds.), Aplicación, discusión y
práctica de las Ciencias Sociales (pp. 140-161). Tirant Lo
Blanch.
Deardoff, D. (2004). The identification and assessment
of Intercultural Competence as a student outcome of international education at
institutions of Higher Education in the United States. (Tesis doctoral) North
Carolina State University.
Deardorff, D. K. (2011). Assessing Intercultural
Competence. New Directions for Institutional Research, 149(1), 65-79.
De
Wit, H. y Jones, E. (2014). We Need to Change the Language of Internationalization.
University World News the Global Window of Higher Education, Issue (343).
Fantini, A. E. (2009). Developing Intercultural
Competencies: An Educational Imperative for the 21st Century. Studies in Language and
Literature, 28(2),
193-213.
De
Zan, A., Paipa, L. y Parra, C. (2011). Las competencias: base para la
internacionalización de la educación superior. Revista Educación en Ingeniería.
Asociación Colombiana de Facultades de Ingeniería. https://www.educacioneningenieria.org/index.php/edi/article/view/113/100
Erickson, F. (1973). What Makes School Ethnography
Ethnographic? Anthropology and Education
Quarterly, 4(2), 10·19.
Gacel-Ávila, J. (2009). Los
programas de grado conjunto y doble titulación en América Latina: tendencias,
retos, oportunidades. Educación global, 13(1), 47-55.
García
Álvarez, D., Soler, M.J. y Cobo Rendon, R. (2019). Programa creciendo fuertes
para la promoción de fortalezas del carácter: una mirada desde sus estudiantes.
Areté. Revista Digital del Doctorado en Educación de la Universidad Central
de Venezuela, 5(9), 81 – 101.
García
Cruz, R., Valencia Ortiz, A. I., Rueda León, L. C., Consuelos Barrios, M. y
Guerrero Rivero, A. M. (2022). Intervención universal selectiva indicada para
docentes: propuesta para el funcionamiento psicológico positivo. Revista
Universidad y Sociedad, 14(2), 201-210.
Goetz, J. P., y Hansen, J.
F. (1974). The
Cultural Analysis of Schooling. Anthropology and Education
quarterly, 5(4), 1-8.
Hernández, R. (2009).
Educación Internacional, desarrollo profesional y conciencia global. Educación Global, 13(1), 47-55.
Hudzik,
J. K.
(2011). Comprehensive
Internationalization. From concept
to action. Association of
International Educators [NAFSA].
Kennedy,
D. (2007). Writing and Using Learning Outcomes: A Practical Guide, Cork: Quality
Promotion Unit. University
College Cork.
Knight,
J. (2005). Un modelo de internacionalización: Respuesta a las nuevas realidades
y retos. En H. de
Wit, I. C.
Jaramillo, J. Gacel-Ávila
y J. Knight.
(Eds.), Educación Superior en América Latina. La dimensión
internacional (pp. 1-38). Banco Mundial/Mayol Ediciones.
Knight, J. (2008). Higher Education in Turmoil. The
Changing World of Internationalization. Sense Publishers.
Laudadío, J. y Mazzitelli,
C. (2019). Formación del profesorado: Estilos de enseñanza y habilidades
emocionales. Revista mexicana de investigación educativa, 24(82),
853-869.
Leask, B.
(2014). Internacionalizando el
currículo y el
aprendizaje de todos
los alumnos.Educación Superior
Internacional, 1(78), 5-6.
Llorent,
V.J.; Zych, I. y Varo-Millán, J.C. (2020). Competencias socioemocionales
autopercibidas en el profesorado universitario en España. Educación XX1, 23(1),
297-318,
Martínez Martí, M. L., (2006). El estudio científico de las
fortalezas trascendentales desde la Psicología Positiva. Clínica y Salud, 17(3),
245-258. https://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=180613871003
Muñoz
Campos, E., Fernández González, A. y Jacott, L. (2018). Bienestar subketivo y
satisfacción vital del profesorado. Revista Iberoamericana sobre Calidad,
Eficacia y Cambio en Educación, 16(1), 105-117.
Nigra,
S., (2020). Competencias interculturales
en estudiantes universitarios. Diálogos sobre educación. Temas actuales en
investigación educativa, 11(21),1-25. https://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=553466654014
Niemiec,
R. M., Rashid, T., y Spinella, M. (2012). Strong
Mindfulness: Integrating Mindfulness and Character Strengths. Journal of Mental Health
Counseling, 34(3),
240– 253.
Organización
para la Cooperación y el Desarrollo Económico [OCDE]. (2018). Pisa,
Preparing our Youth for an Inclusive and Sustainable World. OCDE.
Peterson,
C. y Seligman, M. E. P. (2004). Character Strengths and Virtues. Oxford.
Purdue
University. (2022, December 1st). Writing a literature review. Purdue
University. https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/research_and_citation/conducting_research/writing_a_literature_review.html
Quinteiro Goris, J. A. (2020, 7 de marzo). La
internacionalización de la educación superior: ¿y la medición para cuándo?
UNESCO.
Rashid, T., Anjum, A.,
Lennox, C., Quinlan, D., Niemiec, R. M., Mayerson, D., y Kazemi, F. (2013).
Assessment of character strengths in children and adolescents. In C. Proctor
& P. A. Linley (Eds.), Research,
applications, and interventions for children and adolescents: A positive
psychology perspective (pp. 81–115). Springer Science +
Business Media.
Restrepo,
M. C. y Tabares, L. E. (2000). Métodos de Investigación en
Educación. Revista de Ciencias Humanas, 21(1), 1-9.
Rizo, M. (2009)
Intersubjetividad y comunicación intercultural. Reflexiones desde la sociología
fenomenológica como fuente científica histórica de la comunicología. Perspectivas
de la comunicación, 2(2), 45-53.
Salazar Ibarra y Cervantes
Holguín (2018). Movilidad docente en la Educación Superior: formación integral.
Educación
Global, 22(1),
13-22.
Sälzer, C. and Roczen, N. (2018). Assessing global
competence in PISA 2018: Challenges and approaches to capturing a complex
construct. International Journal of Development Education and Global
Learning, 10(1): 5–20.
https://doi.org/10.18546/IJDEGL.10.1.02
Santamaría-Cárdaba,
N. (2018). Educando para el desarrollo y la ciudadanía global a través de la
psicología positiva. REIDOCREA, 7(1), 98-109.
Seligman M. E. P. (2012). Flourish: A visionary new
understanding of happiness and well-being. Simon and Schuster.
Snyder, C., López, S. y Pedrotti, J. (2011). Positive
psychology: The scientific and practical explorations of human strengths.
Sage Publications, Inc.
Spradley, J. P. y McCurdy, W. (1972). Cultural Experience:
Ethnography in Complex Society. Science Research Associate.
Spradley,
J. P. (1980). Participant observation.
Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Tobón, S. (2008). Formación
basada en competencias. Universidad Veracruzana. https://www.uv.mx/psicologia/files/2015/07/Tobon-S.-Formacion-basada-en-competencias.pdf
Wolcott,
H. F. (1975). Criteria for an Ethnographic Approach to Research in Schools. Human Organization, 34(1),
111·127.
Velázquez Martínez, M. P. y
Pimienta Rosales, V. (2018). Estrategias de vocabulario glosado y cadenas de
vinculación de cohesión léxica en la comprensión lectora de estudiantes de
inglés como lengua extranjera. Educación Global, 22(1), 50-62.
Universidad Veracruzana
[UV]. (2022, 17 de enero). Internacionalización del currículo. Universidad
Veracruzana.
https://lumen.uv.mx/recursoseducativos/internacionalizacion/tema2.html
UNESCO
(2013). Intercultural Competences. Conceptual and Operational Framework.
UNESCO.
Universidad
Juárez Autónoma de Tabasco [UJAT]. (2022). Manual del instructor. UJAT.
Zabalza,
MA. (2004). Diarios de clase. Un instrumento de investigación y desarrollo
profesional. Narcea.